Before you answer, please consider that, while the new Amiga systems being released are somewhat removed from the classics, they are not as far removed as the current Mac machines are from the classic Mac machines (and I don't think anyone is complaining that the latest Mac is not really a Mac -- On second thought, I guess someone is always complaining).
Anyway, please give it some thought. I'm still struggling with this question myself, though I have not yet lost sleep over it. There's probably no right or wrong answer, which makes me somewhat uncomfortable too.
What bothers me the most, is that these same questions keep being asked over and over again, with zero productive answers being come up with, year after year.
Everyone knows that there is no "One" answer that everyone will agree with, so I fail to see the usefulness of bringing up the same question again and again that can never be resolved, and asking the question usually stirs up more disagreement within the community and more disunity between us, so I don't see how it can serve any positive purpose for any of us.
If members here can't do something else, besides post this and similar questions over and over again, something that is productive for the "Amiga" community as a whole, with their time, then perhaps they should do something else with their family or friends instead, that is productive, and/or supportive in some way toward the rest of their lives.