Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Author Topic: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week  (Read 30856 times)

Description:

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Daedalus

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Join Date: Feb 2002
  • Posts: 893
    • Show only replies by Daedalus
    • http://www.robthenerd.com
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #44 on: February 02, 2011, 09:05:27 AM »
Quote from: kolla;611735
@red
Could you ask if they have any plans for some real Amiga keyboards? I mean something like A2000/3000/4000 keyboards, correctly located alt and Amiga keys, ctrl on the right place (the caps I could not care less about), del and help... good old classic keyboard - only with USB. I'm sure I'm not the only one who find it akward to use PC keyboards on Amiga systems.


Yep, I find PC keyboards a little awkward with AmigaOS alright - though I do find them fine with Linux ;)

At the moment these are pretty close:

http://amigakit.leamancomputing.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=37_95&products_id=973

It is just a modified PC keyboard, but the Alt and Amiga keys are in the right place, has Help marked on the Scroll Lock key (where it normally maps to in AmigaOS) and I'm pretty sure there's a patch somewhere out there to remap Ctrl to the Caps Lock key.
Engineers do it with precision
--
http://www.robthenerd.com
 

Offline AmigaNG

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Join Date: Feb 2010
  • Posts: 320
  • Country: 00
    • Show only replies by AmigaNG
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #45 on: February 02, 2011, 09:17:28 AM »
If you are taking question here are mine.

Do you agree with Amiga Inc position that use of the Workbench name could harm other Amiga related products.  (that the whole bases for the court case with Cloanto.)

Do you at least understand the concerns and issues that some Amiga users have with using the name Workbench, epsically calling it version 5.

Do you not see a conflict of similar names Amiga 1000X and AmigaOne X1000.

(try not let him turn this around to say a-eon/hyperion should just be told the same thing to change there names, simple fact is both AmigaOS4 and AmigaOne x1000 projects and brand names where used before CommodreUSA and by calling there products so close to these already existing brand name does feel like a lack of respect to the existing Amiga community and is partly the reason for the hostility towards his company )

Thank you, what ever happens, I'm going to buy a lot of pop corn :)

Offline BigBenAussie

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Join Date: Feb 2004
  • Posts: 313
    • Show only replies by BigBenAussie
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #46 on: February 02, 2011, 09:32:34 AM »
@runequester
These are the sort of questions I have been more than happy to discuss on Commodore-Amiga.org for quite some time as the technology go to, and I have been quite open about many things. I invite interested parties to come and chat there. But please be civil.

It's not like we don't understand your concerns, especially as an a A.org member for the past several years, but in most cases there isn't much that can be done to address them for various reasons. Please don't make me regret posting information here in a thread asking for information.

Barry is a smart guy, and he designed the new C64 over many months with the assistance of a design company and Motorola, both of which are situated in Florida. It was not as easy as you all think. We are poised for production of the cases and close to shooting off a huge order for hardware. I'm actually in charge of IT, hardware and software selection and the development side of things, so it would be more appropriate for me to answer your specific tech questions.

Quote
Linux distro yay/nay

Yay of course. We spoke to MorphOS team, we spoke to Hyperion, I posted on AROS dev forums on Commodore's behalf. You know the threats from Hyperion that are getting in the way of our original intention of further "developing" an Amiga-like OS. No-one is stopping AROS or any alternative OS from being installed on our machines if that is what you want. *I* personally may even fund bounties to support this and other things once things solidify regarding our line-up, although I do not anticipate many surprises. We will incorporate in Workbench 5/X, everything required to facilitate the multi-boot of IcAROS later.

I have said on Commodore-Amiga.org that we will be using 2nd Gen Intel Core(Sandybridge) technology with a focus on NVidia graphics throughout our Amiga line-up. This is a strategic choice, that may allow infiltration into many industries as workstations. An Amiga 2000x running at 5+Ghz with multiple overclocked NVidia graphic cards, and OS flexibility, is a very attractive machine in my eyes, and puts the Amiga brand up with the best desktop computers in the world once more. That is only the beginning, as we may even be able to provide super computing performance on our premium model. And of course there will be opportunities with Newtek Video Toaster integration (which they're calling something else now) on a special Amiga Video Toaster edition. So many avenues can finally open up for the Amiga brand.

While Workbench 5(or X) will not be promoted as Linux any more than Android is, it is common knowledge that it is Linux, and we have this in our FAQ. But don't get too hung up on Linux, as we could just as easily switch to a different platform architecture down the track as alternatives advance and suit our needs.

Quote
What distro will it be based off ?

Sorry, you'll have to wait for that info. Gotta keep you interested.
Sign an NDA and I'll tell you. ;-)
I think it is a very good one and we are dealing with prominent members of that community behind the scenes.

We will differentiate our offering by providing an installer for a large set of common applications, which will become central to the "Creativity and Entertainment" promise of our mission statement. I imagine many are opposed to this, and perceive this as bloat, but just think about what Apple offer, and how great it would be to have quite a bit of that functionality available for Workbench right out of the box. You can always uninstall after the fact. But we are planning to provide a common and expansive software collection from the outset, and champion the open source software cause.

Quote
Will it use Deb or RPM for packages?

Yes.
Sorry, I couldn't resist. ;-)

More info on that later, and a proposed list of apps that will be included. With the aid of the community at Commodore-Amiga.org this app list will be weeded down or built up further. We aren't saying we know everything there is to know, and we actively seek community participation. We want everything to work out of the box. We believe a potential killer app in a mainstream market will be the expansive functionality and application stack that comes pre-loaded. Everything will be at your fingertips, with as minimal resource usage as possible. Hard disk space is super cheap these days. The Amigas will not be cheap, but our high-end premium model. We will have solely Commodore branding for our lower cost hardware. We are actively pursuing interesting design features for the Amiga cases beyond what you see on the website. Hopefully, more on that later.

Quote
What modifications will it include?

You have to understand that our primary concern is time to market, particularly for the C64, so initially not many. We wanted to provide Ubuntu initially, so a branded solution is really an addendum to our plans. We never promised an entirely new OS, and we will never be able to meet the extraordinarily high expectations that many in this classic community have. We will have to see how the OS side if things develops further.

The community, that is is growing around our products, have demonstrated a desire to work on adding retro features, and there are a few people doing stuff behind the scenes, which I will not comment on until they are ready to. In future Commodore USA will focus on integrating more advanced, and likely proprietary features and apps, in either open or closed source as need be. At the moment we are leaning towards our distro being exclusive to Commodore and Amiga machines and that will be required for support and updates.

Commercial OSes like MacOSX and Windows will not remain the same, and we want to have a hand in creating the 2020 computer interface many years before that. Retro will only go so far, and our Amiga Workbench 5/X development will be forward thinking, integrating the best features from open source projects as well as our own innovations. You have to let go to take off.

Quote
Will it be based on an existing desktop environment with a different theme (gnome, kde etc) or be a unique environment?

We have stated on the Commodore-Amiga.org that it is Gnome based. We believe that provides the most common and consistent desktop paradigm similar in many respects to the original Amiga. This will lessen the learning curve for both new and old Amigans. It also will provide stunning effects and eye-candy second to none which is important in attracting the masses to our products. There are various people in the community working on Amigafying the interface further, but just as the Amiga cases are not replicas nor will the UI be a replica of the original or any of it's more recent offshoots. Reminiscent yes.

Quote
If its debian based, will there be repo's specific to this distro?

Oh yes, the intention is to have our own repos for both the OS and applications stack and likely a rolling distro either initially or on a subsequent release. A repository is essential to ensure hardware compatibility. We want to preserve system stability, and we won't be absolutely bleeding edge as it is too risky. Remember this is Linux for the mainstream and we need to also provide support for this. We will test updates on our hardware before it is pushed to the users. Many people have expressed an interest in being beta-testers and they will be more bleeding edge. We will be announcing a Beta-testing program at the appropriate time. It isn't as big a deal as it would be in the case of entirely custom hardware.

Quote
Will the OS be entirely open source or open source with proprietary parts added?

Proprietary parts, either closed or open sourced in future, as well as community driven open source projects will be added at a later stage.

We anticipate an commercial App store before the end of the year, which may also include Windows programs that work through WINE, as well as Flash, Mono, Java apps and any other framework we can provide etc. That App store will be open to all Linux distros but will be a standard fixture on Workbench. Other distros also have plans for a common app store, and we will see how we can integrate and provide further value to commercial developers as well as bedroom coders.

If all goes well, I anticipate, that we will be sponsoring demo parties in 2012, if not sooner.

Quote
The bleeding edge PC with a C= logo has been done and it barely raised a blip.

We're doing things differently and our success will not hinge on a narrow set of products.
We will also be offering a range of lower end hardware with our compact VIC line. The Amiga name will be associated with our OS efforts across all products, and with our high-end high-performance line. The Retro line will be somewhere in the middle in terms of performance, and we'll do a C64cx and Amiga 500x, once the C64 and Amiga desktops are out.

So the roadmap is, C64x and the compact VIC line first, including a VIC-Book netbook, then Amigas, then more retro cases, and all the while with the OS maturing. By christmas 2011 hopefully things will look entirely different and your doubts about us will have been well and truly quelled. Hopefully, in this time we will have poured siginificant resources into our OS which will slowly mature to provide sufficient interfaces for a tablet and other touch based technology. The upcoming VIC-Touch may even be a test-bed for this tech.
 

Offline BigBenAussie

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Join Date: Feb 2004
  • Posts: 313
    • Show only replies by BigBenAussie
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #47 on: February 02, 2011, 09:33:58 AM »
Please realise that our focus is broader than the retro hobby market, and that we are looking more at a mainstream market, in order to recoup the development costs of products. It is for that reason, that classic Amiga USB keyboard replicas or classic hardware and software projects are not within our business plan. There are a multitude of existing projects that can service the classic niche without our involvement, and we definitely do not need a finger in every pie.

I cannot speak on the Amiga Inc. case as I am not involved. IANAL but I imagine Amiga Inc, lawyers will argue in a manner to protect their revenue stream. Amiga Inc. is not fighting on behalf of Hyperion of course. Losing the Workbench name will potentially damage their revenue possibilities from AmigaOS, which I believe is why AmigaOS was sited as an example. We could also just as easily have been brought up I guess, depending on the Lawyer's knowledge of our recent activities and whether they are specifically relevant to the case in question. Don't worry too much about it, or read too much into this. Whatever happens we'll be fine.

The only confusion may be with the original A1000, so as you know we use x as a suffix across our whole replica and Amiga line to differentiate from the originals. The labelling on the machines probably wont even feature the x. You know that Hyperion's product has a One behind the word Amiga, you know it has an X in front of the 1000. All other confusions are unavoidable. I'm afraid you're going to have to get over it.
« Last Edit: February 02, 2011, 10:05:18 AM by BigBenAussie »
 

Offline Kesa

  • Ninja Fruit Slasher
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Join Date: Sep 2010
  • Posts: 2408
    • Show only replies by Kesa
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #48 on: February 02, 2011, 10:10:52 AM »
If you really want to impress me you can ask the mother of all questions:

Who is Amiga.inc? :confused:

Is Amigainc run by humans or is it controlled by a hyper intelligent sentient supercomputer? :confused:

What do they intend to do with it in the long term?   :confused:
Even my cat doesn\'t like me.
 

Offline adz

  • Knight of the Sock
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Join Date: Aug 2003
  • Posts: 2961
    • Show only replies by adz
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #49 on: February 02, 2011, 10:22:34 AM »
Quote from: Franko;611666
You kidding... this is better than the telly... :)

(some of us lead a sad life you know... :()


Tell...eeee o_O
 

Offline Franko

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jun 2010
  • Posts: 5707
    • Show only replies by Franko
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #50 on: February 02, 2011, 10:40:39 AM »
Quote from: BigBenAussie;611769
The only confusion may be with the original A1000, so as you know we use x as a suffix across our whole replica and Amiga line to differentiate from the originals. The labelling on the machines probably wont even feature the x. You know that Hyperion's product has a One behind the word Amiga, you know it has an X in front of the 1000. All other confusions are unavoidable. I'm afraid you're going to have to get over it.


Well if this is CUSAs official standpoint on the use of the brand names/trademarks (ie: C64, Amiga, Workbench)... :(

Then I've officially just donned me tin helmet, flak jacket and armed meself to the teeth with exploding squirrels.... :madashell:

Get Ready Boy's IT's WAR... :uzi::quickdraw::destroy:

(Now where'd I leave me tickling stick... :))
 

Offline AmigaNG

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Join Date: Feb 2010
  • Posts: 320
  • Country: 00
    • Show only replies by AmigaNG
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #51 on: February 02, 2011, 10:54:41 AM »
Thank you for the response, just a little comment its a tad unprofessional and unnecessary to add the line “I'm afraid you're going to have to get over it.” I completely understand you now own/license to the Amiga name to do with as you want, I was more asking weather you understand and admit that calling these product so close to pre-existing Amiga project is going to cause problems and annoyance from the Amiga community.  
 
Put it this way your company has already admitted its not happy that this very site has amiga.org, now imagine if I started a company called it FommodoreUK and used the same cases called it the A1XXX and place a linux OS on it and called it Kickstart 5.1 you wouldn't be very happy would you.   That all I'm saying and I hope you understand why so many people are negative towards you.  

 Saying things like, we own the name, we can do what we want, deal with, doesn't help matters. You could at least say “we understand you concerns and some of the objections to the name, these products names are not final, and we will take you concerns into consideration” even if its a complete lie that what a proper PR or CTO would do.
« Last Edit: February 02, 2011, 10:58:04 AM by AmigaNG »
 

Offline djrikki

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Join Date: Mar 2010
  • Posts: 346
    • Show only replies by djrikki
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #52 on: February 02, 2011, 11:39:02 AM »
@redrumloa

I have a question for him.  Did he enjoy the free postal catalogue from the company based in Florida that sells Viagra products? :lol::lol:
« Last Edit: February 02, 2011, 11:44:40 AM by djrikki »
 

Offline J-Golden

  • TOP SECRET USER!!!
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jun 2002
  • Posts: 1325
  • Country: us
  • Gender: Male
    • Show only replies by J-Golden
    • http://about.me/J.Golden
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #53 on: February 02, 2011, 12:04:38 PM »
Well, I am impressed with the responses we are getting.  In the past we've had companies that either wanted to do everything retro (Keep the Amiga classic) or strip the name for something totally left field (Amiga Anywhere).
 
What BigBenAussie has leaked to us to me actually makes sense.  They have paid the money for the name and want to make it into a worth while system again.  Can that really be done with keeping to the "classic" arcitecture and business plan?
 
Not really.
 
Today's computer market isn't the same. System wars are now more in the Video game market in that sense.  Trying to do it with computer hardware is sure fire way to lose all your money.
 
I've always thought that the biggest problem with ANY Linux distro is that there wasn't any solid backing to it.  If the everyday user is going to get into Linux, it'll be through a company that makes ONE build and simplifies the process and trouble shooting for the masses.  In my head, that is exactly their model.  I could be wrong, but hey, that's why I'm not paid for my opinion :)
 
As for some of his comments, mind you, we really can't complain about what he has or hasn't said since we aren't part of the company.  We have not paid thousands and thousands of dollars into this venture so, we aren't owed any explinations.  The whole "deal with it" comment didn't bother me becasue I took the whole text as more of a member talking and sharing info, not an official press release.
 
What really comes of this?  I have no clue.  It could crash and burn for all I know just like everything else that is labled Amiga.  It could turn out to be a fraud; Hey, it could be the most elaborate trick of Doom Master's YET!  I really really HOPE not on any of those accounts.
 
So, howz about we all grab a nice cup of coacoa, and relax by a warm fire while visions of Zool's and Boing Balls dance in our head...  and wait to see what comes of it all.;)
AMIGA: (NOUN) THE FIRST COMPUTER THAT BRIDGED THE GAP BETWEEN HUMANITY AND TECHNOLOGY.
 

Offline Franko

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jun 2010
  • Posts: 5707
    • Show only replies by Franko
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #54 on: February 02, 2011, 12:18:08 PM »
Quote from: BigBenAussie;611768
You have to understand that our primary concern is time to market, particularly for the C64, so initially not many. We wanted to provide Ubuntu initially, so a branded solution is really an addendum to our plans. We never promised an entirely new OS, and we will never be able to meet the extraordinarily high expectations that many in this classic community have. We will have to see how the OS side if things develops further.


With you obviously being chief mouthpiece for CUSA could you at least get you story straight before you type some of this drivel, as quoted above you say "We never promised an entirely new OS, and we will never be able to meet the extraordinarily high expectations that many in this classic community have." yet on the official CUSA website your company claims in regard to Workbench 5

Quote
Feeling nostalgic? Workbench 5.0 will also be 100% Commodore compatible, able to run classic 8-bit, 16-bit and 32-bit era software via emulation. A beautiful user interface allows you to easily peruse games for the Commodore PET, Vic20, C16, C64, C128 and AMIGA. No need to bother with floppy disks, as practically every game you ever owned is now readily available on the internet.


Now in my books these so called "extraordinarily high expectations" that you claim you can't meet would be that Workbench 5 IS 100% Commodore compatible as the website clearly claims, but here you are saying that this in an extraordinarily high expection... :confused:

Confused... yup I sure am... IS Workebench 5.0 100% Commodore compatible as this claim clearly leads one to believe that Workbench 5 will be able to run every single piece of software ever written for the Amiga (including stuff that "bangs the metal" as they say).

So which one is it, Workebench 5 is 100% Commodore compatible or "extraordinarily high expectations", if I wasn't confused before I sure as hell am now... :insane:

Or does the term "100% Commodore compatible" really mean Commodore as in CommodoreUSA and not Commodore as in the original and genuine Commodore Business Machines... :confused:

Not very good at being a public spokesman for this company are you... :)
 

Offline psxphill

Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #55 on: February 02, 2011, 12:45:47 PM »
Quote from: Franko;611783
Confused... yup I sure am... IS Workebench 5.0 100% Commodore compatible as this claim clearly leads one to believe that Workbench 5 will be able to run every single piece of software ever written for the Amiga (including stuff that "bangs the metal" as they say).
 
So which one is it, Workebench 5 is 100% Commodore compatible or "extraordinarily high expectations", if I wasn't confused before I sure as hell am now... :insane:

Workbench 5 is linux, which can run uae or vice just fine.
 
The "extraordinarily high expectations" refer to critisism that they are using open source software instead of writing it all from scratch.
 
I don't think it was that confusing.
 
Quote from: AmigaNG;611777
Saying things like, we own the name, we can do what we want, deal with, doesn't help matters. You could at least say “we understand you concerns and some of the objections to the name, these products names are not final, and we will take you concerns into consideration” even if its a complete lie that what a proper PR or CTO would do.

You'd prefer if he lied? Wouldn't that just create more bad feeling in the future?
« Last Edit: February 02, 2011, 12:50:09 PM by psxphill »
 

Offline Manu

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Join Date: Feb 2004
  • Posts: 252
    • Show only replies by Manu
    • http://www.cartoonspace.net
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #56 on: February 02, 2011, 01:16:27 PM »
Quote from: J-Golden;611782
Well, I am impressed with the responses we are getting.  In the past we've had companies that either wanted to do everything retro (Keep the Amiga classic) or strip the name for something totally left field (Amiga Anywhere).
 
What BigBenAussie has leaked to us to me actually makes sense.  They have paid the money for the name and want to make it into a worth while system again.  Can that really be done with keeping to the "classic" arcitecture and business plan?
 
Not really.
 
Today's computer market isn't the same. System wars are now more in the Video game market in that sense.  Trying to do it with computer hardware is sure fire way to lose all your money.
 
I've always thought that the biggest problem with ANY Linux distro is that there wasn't any solid backing to it.  If the everyday user is going to get into Linux, it'll be through a company that makes ONE build and simplifies the process and trouble shooting for the masses.  In my head, that is exactly their model.  I could be wrong, but hey, that's why I'm not paid for my opinion :)
 

Well put. I agree on your points. Take Linux Mint for example it has it's own polished look, it's themed in a way that you see immidiately that it's Linux Mint. And it has been made easy to use. You could build an new Amiga like OS the same way. You will have to do much more work than just make a new skin but I now see why it can be done.

So here's how to build an Amiga, it can be done in two ways:

1)You take an old "Amiga" (AmigaOS,MorphOS,AROS) you repaint, polish it put some glitter on it (I mean all the coding of course and that takes let's say 10+ years) and then you look for apps to use. You then realize that all Amiga apps are atleast 15 years old and that there are many opens source variants that does the same job much better (Think: OO, Gimp, Blender, Inkscape etc.) You then start to port them to your "AmigaOS" (takes 10 years to get the most important).  So you got your renewed AmigaOS & apps in no time (20 years or so). ;-)

2)Take something already up todate (Linux distro) stuff away everything you don't need, repaint, polish, put some glitter on it. (takes 2+ years to go out of beta, maybe 4 to final polished version you're very proud of). Look for apps to use. You realize you don't need to port them because they where made to work for your chosen OS. You got your renewed AmigaOS in notime compared to the alternative (4 years or so)

Compare the two: Put the machines side by side they both look alike. You have made the CLI looks the same, all windows, screen dragging(TM) of course :) You think you can tell the difference but they both boot as fast, both has equally snappy UI. You look at the apps you use, yup they're the same all from the open source world. OK you have to run the old stuff in a emulator on one of the machines but hey that gets rarely used and emulation works good enough for that. ;-)

So which one is Amiga enough for you? The goals are the same it's only how you get there which is different. To me it doesn't matter but I'd pick the one that has the lowest entry level cost and the one that can get new apps more frequently. I'd dump the one that I'm missing out on. The one that makes me have yet another operating system and even worse yet another machine sitting next to it.

Yeah, reality is harsh but this is how I see it. And Carl,Dave, R&J, Dale isn't coming back to make me a "real" Amiga either ;-)
AmigaOS or MorphOS on x86 would sell orders of magnitude more than the current, hardware-intensive solutions. And they\\\'d go faster. --D.Haynie
__________________________________________
http://www.cartoonspace.net
 

Offline dwaldrop

  • Lifetime Member
  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Join Date: Dec 2006
  • Posts: 70
    • Show only replies by dwaldrop
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #57 on: February 02, 2011, 01:28:38 PM »
@Manu - Well put.  I thinkyou have nailed the realistic options.  

I am willing to give CUSA a chanec to shop a product before I pass judgement.  If they can adapt a Linux system to being the ease of use and feel of Amiga PLUS include a more seamless UAE, I would have to seriously consider them.  

@Red  - Thank you for taking the time and effort to do this for the community.  I appreciate your efforts!!

-David
 

Offline Khephren

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Join Date: Feb 2002
  • Posts: 606
    • Show only replies by Khephren
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #58 on: February 02, 2011, 01:54:08 PM »
@Manu

How to say this...Amiga OS functions nothing like Linux.

'Take something already up todate (Linux distro) stuff away everything you don't need, repaint, polish, put some glitter on it'  -so it's really that easy? I want an Amiga that functions like an Amiga, not a themed gnu/linux box.

'they both boot as fast' -how do you know this? My Amiga boots up one hell of a lot faster than windows or my Ubuntu install.

'both has equally snappy UI' again it does not exist, so how do you know?

'You think you can tell the difference' the difference is not just the skin, it's what is under it. I find linux file system inelegent, and the UI and fundamentals too technical. I do not find this with the Amiga.
 

Offline Amiga_Nut

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jan 2007
  • Posts: 926
    • Show only replies by Amiga_Nut
Re: Ok guys, I will be doing a report on Commodore USA this week
« Reply #59 from previous page: February 02, 2011, 02:03:42 PM »
Quote from: Manu;611793
Well put. I agree on your points. Take Linux Mint for example it has it's own polished look, it's themed in a way that you see immidiately that it's Linux Mint. And it has been made easy to use. You could build an new Amiga like OS the same way. You will have to do much more work than just make a new skin but I now see why it can be done.

So here's how to build an Amiga, it can be done in two ways:

1)You take an old "Amiga" (AmigaOS,MorphOS,AROS) you repaint, polish it put some glitter on it (I mean all the coding of course and that takes let's say 10+ years) and then you look for apps to use. You then realize that all Amiga apps are atleast 15 years old and that there are many opens source variants that does the same job much better (Think: OO, Gimp, Blender, Inkscape etc.) You then start to port them to your "AmigaOS" (takes 10 years to get the most important).  So you got your renewed AmigaOS & apps in no time (20 years or so). ;-)

2)Take something already up todate (Linux distro) stuff away everything you don't need, repaint, polish, put some glitter on it. (takes 2+ years to go out of beta, maybe 4 to final polished version you're very proud of). Look for apps to use. You realize you don't need to port them because they where made to work for your chosen OS. You got your renewed AmigaOS in notime compared to the alternative (4 years or so)

Compare the two: Put the machines side by side they both look alike. You have made the CLI looks the same, all windows, screen dragging(TM) of course :) You think you can tell the difference but they both boot as fast, both has equally snappy UI. You look at the apps you use, yup they're the same all from the open source world. OK you have to run the old stuff in a emulator on one of the machines but hey that gets rarely used and emulation works good enough for that. ;-)

So which one is Amiga enough for you? The goals are the same it's only how you get there which is different. To me it doesn't matter but I'd pick the one that has the lowest entry level cost and the one that can get new apps more frequently. I'd dump the one that I'm missing out on. The one that makes me have yet another operating system and even worse yet another machine sitting next to it.

Yeah, reality is harsh but this is how I see it. And Carl,Dave, R&J, Dale isn't coming back to make me a "real" Amiga either ;-)


None of those two are Amiga, MoS/AOS4 are just Amiga OS boxes not Amigas as they all need UAE to run what made Amiga an Amiga (OCS/ECS/AGA) and don't read original Amiga floppy disks. And C= USA's PC Linux machines are definitely not Amiga at all, Amiga stickers+PC maybe ;)

A new real Amiga at the very least =

1. Run Dpaint III without UAE on it
2. Save IFF pic onto floppy disk
3. Take floppy disk and put it inside A500 etc
4. Load pic from floppy into Dpaint running on A500 without cross dos etc
5. Incorporate the pic into a Blitzbasic demo running on A500

(the whole point of the exercise, use Dpaint on a virtual 040 via UAE, use the output on a real Amiga as intended)

That doesn't even allow for the whingers going on about banging the metal for games only :)