KennyR,
Thanks for the reply, you made many interesting points. This is the sort of constructive criticism I have no qualms with reading. :-)
It's not worth me banging on about things I have already mentioned in my previous post, I think I made my point quite clearly. But I must address this:
I think saying that it is boring or stupid to criticise is just one of the forms of defensiveness I outlined above.
Of course I think you are right, criticism is fine. But I think it is boring and stupid to repeatedly attack. That's the thing I don't understand. Why attack? Are the more vocal people really so personally and emotionally involved? Why can't we keep things civil?
Also, the anti-amiga inc threads I have read contain many personal attacks aimed at and coming from amiga inc supporters/cheerleaders. If such contempt is felt between the Pro and the Anti, why try and help these people? I say let them follow their beloved name and suffer their own fate!
I am not a name follower. I'm simply a fan of the classic miggy keeping up-to-date with Amiga news. And if at some point in the future MorphOS or OS4 seems to be something I might like to own, I'll make the necessary purchases. ;-) At the moment I am playing about with AROS, which seems very cool. :-)
You suggest I (and people who feel like me) stay out of the threads that contain attacks, trolls and flames. On the surface this seems like a wise idea. But what does that leave? There are so few peaceful threads for rational discussion. And I'd miss interesting posts like these.
edit:
oh yeah...
Most of these people wouldn't care if I insulted Microsoft in the same way - my avatar pees on them and I've had no complaints of being a troll yet for that!
...And you'll get no complaints from me. ;-)
But M$ is a truely evil, dominating multi-national corporation that breaks laws and gets away with it to keep their monopoly. We should unite and bring down these bastards. But if these forums were polluted with messages like this in the same quantity as anti-amiga inc and anti-genesi comments, I think it would get annoying.