Yes, currently the A3000 is my main rig, so I'm not using the xrgb very often now. But it works great. Honestly, I can't compare it to s-video cause I never used the s-video. But it's very satisfactory, it stands quite close to what I get from A3000 onboard scandoubler (amber). I usually get them second hand from japan yahoo auctions. they cost about 150-200$ depending on the condition, etc. Contact me if you need one.