There hasn't been a clear owner of OS3.1 or 3.9 in years so why should any end-user pay fees to Hyperion or anyone else who is hocking a classic Amiga OS unless that dealer has a license to distribute or offers some service after the sale?
Hold on. How come you know the licensing issues between the dealers and the manufacturer, and how come that you believe that the copies are sold without licenses. You can hardly know how the details. There are certainly licensing models that allow parties to redistribute the product for an extended period, or for a given upper bound of copies, both of which might not have been reached or exploited. In other words, all I'm seeing is that you are trying to find an excuse for your lazyness.
I can tell you what my contract tells, and I can ensure you that it did not provide a "full stop" for distribution of my constributions after two years. So from my perspective, selling 3.9 after all these years is still fine, even if I do not get my share.
Let's be real here. The Amiga for all intents and purposes is dead. The OS is dead as well.
No, it's not. Have you seen the announcement at Amiga32? And even if it were, you still not holding the copyright, and still cannot copy it as you wish.
Anyone still using a classic Amiga is a hobbyist and should not be under constant attack for obtaining whatever variant of Amiga OS 1 thru 3.9 that they choose from whatever source.
Everybody using the Amiga should understand that years of work went into the system, and that this requires a *little bit* of compensation.
It's funny that I don't see the copyright Nazis coming out of the woodwork with my other hobby systems, like my Timex-Sinclair ZX-81, or my C-64.
Probably because the situation is different? I cannot tell where the copyright for the C64 "Os" went, but as far as AmigaOs is concerned, it is still being worked on, and there are still stakeholders for it.
Buying a copy of OS3.x from a dealer at this point in time is simply ridiculous.
You know what is ridiculous? That people expect something gets done for free, and consider software to be worthless.
And attacking people for downloading and/or modding a dead OS is simply ludicrous.
No, not at all. It remains piracy no matter what. If you want to support the Os, and you do not yet have a license for the system, you'd better buy one. How on earth can you expect that anyone should support the system without charge just to please the pirates.