To me it seems like Windows 8 will turn out to be the new Windows ME, and because of this upgrade offer, I belive Microsoft have their doubts as well.
The Win9x start menu was one of the things Microsoft really did a good job with, but of course they had to mess it up with the later versions of Windows. Launching applications from a small menu by using only two mouse-clicks was of course way too easy, so they had to find ways to make this more ackward for the user.
Guess I will be sticking with Vista for as long as I can, since it's the last Windows version where it's still possible to get the classic start menu, and I will not upgrade to Win8 even if I got payed to do so.
Mark my words, Windows 8 will fail considerably on the desktop market, so Microsoft will be forced to either make an update which brings back the start menu, or they will rush out the next Windows version where it will be re-implemented there instead.
Everybody I have talked to are sceptical to Windows 8, and even my father have heard rumors about 8 being no good.
PS! Sorry about being on-topic folks :-)