I don't understand all this sharpness. Commodore USA promised a revival to the Commodore 64 and delivered the product in 6 months. You may find it beautiful or awful, but it proved to exist and to sell, so in a nutshell CUSA was right and most people here and there was wrong. I wonder why most people can't understand their vision of the market, since it's so simple.
First of all, new Amigas will be x64, like many other computers, servers and workstation. They won't be the 'different machines' they could be 25 years ago. They will have to compete on a standardized platform market which is used on practically every field of human activities. If they have to differ somehow from Macs, from Dell and HP workstations, they must provide first class hardware components in a clean, personal, recognizable case line. They can't compete in the consumer market because there's no room for new payers, nor there's room for good incomes. You can buy a great PC for less than $1000, why should you buy another one for $2500 or more?
So the only option to leverage the Amiga brand is selling it as professional computing solution, exactly what Commodore tried to do with the A1000, at least initially. Then they discovered they needed a successor for the C64, and since the C128 wasn't a good idea (and 16 bit platforms were arising at the same time), they brought the A500 to the masses. The problem today is there's no need for a new A500 anymore. A similar machine (a PC with an A500-like case, similar to the C64x) would make happy some vintage maniacs like the C64x did, but it wouldn't fit any other rational need. For instance, I am using the case and the keyboard of a broken A1200 as keyrah-driven USB keyboard for my main PC, I don't need an A500-replica to be happier. Don't forget, then, that old Commodore sold about 20 millions of C64, but only 7 of Amigas (all models together). If you would have been Barry, what model you'd choose for a replica?
If Commodore USA can afford all the needs of corporates (customer care and support at first), I can only welcome the rebirth of Amigas as serious, professional cutting edge workstations. It's the best the name deserves. Yes, I won't have the money to afford one, but at least they will be machines I will DREAM to make mine again, like they did looooong ago. And, thanks to the x64 platform, they will also have a future, unlike some old computers we all love and still miss.