What if this machine comes along doing something that no other machine can do? That would be utterly gobsmacking, and is teetering on the very edge of possibility... And what if the machine could also run everything people know and currently tolerate, becoming the first computer in the home, not the fourth?
Don't ask me what that "something" might be, because I don't know
...but it's what the A1000 did.
If it doesn't do something exceptional (which is the word they use), then it's all just marketing and bluster.
Market share is critical, for sure, but what's the market: is it every computer user, every geek, every former Amiga owner? The value proposition is different for each, and that can radically skew the perceived value and acceptable price point.
Fun debate, and at last some possibility of something that's a spiritual successor to the Amiga, maybe?