No, the A1200 doesn't need KS 3.1 to boot off a hardrive. KS 3.0 does the job just fine.
Put your ear on the hard drive. Turn on the Amiga. If you don't hear noise, then the hard drive must be dead. Try on another Amiga or another machine (with a USB to IDE/small IDE dongle if you have one).
The guy probably didn't lie to you, but because of shipping maybe the hard drive croaked. Who knows.
As for throwing the board, although a rather unorthodox technique what it tells me is that there was some badly seated chips or something like that. In other words the problem you had before was a MECHANICAL problem, not an electronic. Which makes TOTAL sense, because when you move/ship components and they wiggle around in the box, some can get dislodged or dislocated. That's what it's ALWAYS a good idea after you move a computer to make sure everything is SEATED properly (cards and chips), usually by hand, not by throwin across the room (imagine if Kendra walked in the room at that moment and saw you doing that!! She'd think you 're a spaz!)
Cheers and good luck at discus
