I think, especially in the A1's case, it's too little too late, and horrificly overpriced. AGP 2x is ancient. The Amiga is best remembered for it's games, so surely it should have some strength in this department? I realise that there was more to the Amiga than JUST games, but existing platforms more than have things covered.
To me the A1 is nothing but an overpriced way of running an overrated OS. Don't get me wrong, Amiga OS's tiny size on Disc makes it a joy to use, it loads in a flash (at least on WinUAE) and after enough weeks of downloads, can do about anything Windows can. I can't speak for OS4, I've not ever used anything above OS3.1, though I'm sure that it likely offers little more than eye candy.
The fact Eyetech haven't even bothered to manufacture dedicated case designs with an Amiga logo doesn't help it's identity. It doesn't come with a PCI board with classic hardware, so it's nothing more than an overpriced outdated PPC system. I wish it were otherwise. I don't think it could be though, there's just not enough supporters of Amiga anymore, which kind of makes sense why Eyetech have not made a special case, and give nothing to make it anymore Amiga than an unfinished OS, but surprises me that a lot of the motherboard technology is so far behind the times as a result.
At this price, I don't just think the classic Amiga is an endangered species, I think ANY form of Amiga is an endangered species. But then really, we all knew this 10 years ago. It's only our love of the system that has kept the dream alive this long.
I'm not trying to be unecessarily negative, I just think it's a shame that finally someone builds a new Amiga, and instead of being technology of tomorrow (that's how the original Amiga felt to me when I got it) it's technology of yesterday. No big software companies are going to support it, only a few enthusiasts will buy it, and it'll be yet another nail in the Amiga's coffin (though I'm surprised there's any wood showing that a nail can be driven in anymore anyway)
BUT, that's just my opinion. Perhaps some people REALLY do believe that Amiga will live (the classic hardware though???)