Question still remains - has John even tried Windows 8 yet, or is the incessant badmouthing still based on "facts" garnered from "credible" blogs and stories passed down from the ancients?
You might not see value in something, but that doesn't make it crap out of the box when there's no facts and actual usage case presented.
I love hearing peoples opinions on things, but they often fall flat when people readily admit they haven't even tried the things they are smack talking.
Win 8 is what it is, and anyone that's used it will tell you the pro's and con's. IIRC, the guy was the same guy that claimed tablets and smartphones were a passing fancy and that no one in their right mind would ever have a credible use for something like an ipad. Might be of no use to you, but the people virtually throwing money at companies like Samsung and Apple, well - BS walks, the market talks, eh.
It's the ones that have no experience with things that present things as facts that often become the muttering old men in the corners, shaking their fists at "these damned newfangled kids!11!!!"
Sorry, the "I've seen a screenshot and read a blog and that tells me something sucks" doesn't cut it.