"should we segregate in the fashion that
Frodon and others believe?"
Not all the time. I like the debates and disagreements when they don't get out of hand. But that "good and bad" thread made a very interesting read and it was a nice change. I think people should be allowed to request (from time to time) that no flames/abuse or opposing opinions are posted so that the people participating in the thread can concentrate on asking/answering serious on-topic questions, instead of defending themselves and their opinions and fighting back the attacks.
Not all the time tho... It would get very boring wouldn't it?
-zudo
(edits - spelling errors)