Im a big retro game fan, the classic amiga is my favorite system, and I get a kick out of seeing what results can be obtained with aga and so I do get it, but sometimes I think it's easy to look back with rose tinted glasses. Although I agree gaming can be quite generic these days, it again isnt too far different from the amigas heyday, the main thing that's different is the genres. FPS's today, platformers or 2d shooters yesterday.
I don't agree. I've been in the games industry now for over 13 years, and it's gone from someone with a passionate idea, or a small group of like minded people, to teams of hundreds, and design by comittee. The commitee normally being dominated by corporates with no passion for games.
Video games play it a lot safer than in decades past, because they are so expensive to make. Obviously the coporate mentality was there in the amiga era as well, but it's much worse now.
That's why I moved from next gen to handheld stuff. Good stuff still gets made, but you really have to fight against the publishers, and generally lose.