I once made an Arcade of Pinball Fantasies CD32 Version that accepted quarters and was in an Arcade Cabinet I made. Everyone loved it but it was sort of incomplete...eventually I dismantled it and trashed it (Not the CD32)
Anyway I think Pinball Fantasies is great. But Believe SLam Tilt is quite possibly the most fun game ever made on the Amiga and most complete and arcade quality accurate.
Pinball illusions seems more realistic though, but its not about that....I usually find when a Pinball simulator is too realisitic, that it not as fun.