Is it cool to dump links to ks roms and WB adfs now?

[TheBilgeRat]

Ack!  I'm not trying to give anyone a hard time.  However, let me clear up some misinformation here:

First let's talk about Intellectual Property and Copyright within the US.

Have you ever thought about how IP differs from PP (Physical Property)?  Well, one is tangible and the other is not.  This makes a BIG deal in the courts.

Copyright was created in 1790 (in the US) but did not cover computer code until the 1970s (no kidding).  Databases were in the 1960s but that is entirely different than computer code.

Now, how does one get a Copyright?  

A.  Mounds of paperwork that need to be filed
B.  Holding Franko hostage until the US Government relents (Sorry Franko :-)
C.  Gobs of money
D.  Nothing

D would be the correct answer

If I doodle on my paper placemat while waiting for my food from iHop that drawing is automatically copyrighted.  Now, I have to proactively FIGHT for my copyright.  Franko comes to my table while I'm in the restroom, steels my doodle and spends the next ten years selling in to famous places without a peep from me.  Then I decide to sue, I am going to have a tough time defending my copyright as I think the court would rule its PD now.  I.E.  I did nothing to defend my Copyright for ten years...

Let's look at the Court:

Four Factors the Court Uses to determine Fair Use VS Copyright Infringement:

1.  Nature and use of the material in terms of commercial or non-profit use

2.  The nature of the copyrighted work. (Creative work has more protection than a factual based work).  

3.  Amount and significance of the work

4.  The effect of the use on the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.

Of these four only one is weighted significantly more than the others.  Care to guess?  If you said 4 you are right!

You have to have Fair Use or the world would be more screwed up.  Fair Use allows for reviews, advertisements, and just speaking about other people's work.  

Now, if my doodle was awesome and I'm selling zillions of them all over the world but Franko put a thumbnail picture of it in a review of my doodle on his site that is Fair Use.

If he was making copies -full-size- and selling them then we would a problem.

Vice-Versa, I cannot put a copyrighted work in the PD and then change my mind later.  Now, I saw somebody mention Polly and Copyright so lets examine that:

If Walnut Creek or Franko put together a disc of PD software for mass distribution then WC or Franko owns the copyright for the disc but not the contents of the disc.  Also, I can't put an application on Franko's disc as PD or even shareware and then later decide that its commercial and sue people for using it without paying.  

Further, Amiga, Petro, whoever, put their IP on a disc for mass distribution with a magazine and that Petro was not receiving residuals from (like a reseller).  If the message from him was accurate in the post I saw here.

There is a term call Prior Art that comes into play here as well.  I could say well Petro released it free to anyone and even put it on an Amiga Format Disc for distribution.



Great Tips:

1.  If you are a college student you have carte-blanc!  You can pretty much do anything with other copyrighted works and get away with it.  Now let me put that in context:  You are a struggling film student and you want to make your first movie but 'borrow' some music for your film or footage from other films you will get away with it.

The court is very sympathetic to struggling college students in writing, music, film, and theatre.  Quentin Tarantino used to tell young filmmakers to take a class in college and then just make their first film.  You get all the protection to show people what you can do.

2.  How to defend your song, movie script, play, or novel for $1.00?  A long time ago I was a film student (my first film was Sundance but I lost the Oscar for best picture) and this is how everybody does it on the cheap.

-Buy a mailing envelop
-Take your IP (song, movie script, whatever) and stick it in the envelop
-Mail it to yourself
-Read posts by Franko until your own package arrives
-DO NOT OPEN IT
-Take it to a bank or some place safe
-NEVER OPEN IT

Now submit your scripts or song to publishers.  WAIT!  What if they try to steal it (this happens all the time) they have more money than me!  They could say they had the idea for the movie or song first!  Not to worry, you can now sue them.  But WAIT how will the court know that your script idea was first??  Did you know that unopened mail packages not only have a date and time stamp but the Court looks highly on the Postal System?

You claim that ACME stole you movie idea and here is the UNOPENED mail package that shows when you wrote your script before they did.  Ta Da!   You have won your case!

No kidding, this happens a lot.  'Coming to America' was won this way between the writer and Eddie Murphy.

Did you know that Deluxe Paint was a big deal in the world of Copyright?  You see, EA said that anything drawn in DP was the property of EA.  Users sued saying that what they did in DP was theirs.  The Court sided with the users. I am shocked that EA would suggest such a thing but life was different in 1985 I guess...


Cheers!
-P

Quoted for sheer awesome. :afro:

[Matt_H]

Which is pretty much what I said at the time. And even downloading Future Publishing's Amiga Format CD ISOs is illegal to be honest. If you don't believe me ask Polly who is the rights administrator and she will confirm it is not legal.

This is the technicality I was referring to in my prior post. Thanks for bringing it up, I was just too tired to string my thoughts together the other day.