So, one step in your search for the "truth" in this mess is to stop listen to one of the sides? Sounds more like a "blind follower"-thing to me....
This is a comment that you sir (or madam) are not qualified to make whatsoever.
I and my friends have paid on average, about $90.00 per year, every single year since 1997 to hear Amiga Inc speak. I have personally heard Bill McEwen speak on at least 6 occassions at shows over the last few years. Out of all those shows, and all those speeches, not a single solitary thing that we have ever been told has come true with the exception of the (now) presence of the AmigaOne motherboard (which incidentally was promised to initially available in 2001).
As such, in my eyes, I simply see absolutely no reason for me personally to spend another dime to watch the "magic show". Like a child who has seen the circus one too many times, watching the clowns get in and out of the tiny car loses it's fascination.
As I said however, I'd be more than enthusiastic to see the AmiWest crew allow both of them a bit of time to make their case, on the same stage.