It only works with a floppy drive and/or LEDs attached. NOT with CD-Rs or 3.5" HD (either standing alone or hooked to the IDE port). It also works with the ATX-AT attached, and the AT-Amiga on top, but not with the mobo plugged in.
It does seem like a short, but from where I cannot imagine, as all individual components are verified working. The only thing I can think of is that the 4-way square could possibly need jumpering or something.
Sounds complicated I know, I dread speaking to P.C. AGAIN trying to explain the situation. I fear that both PSUs are in perfect working order, but only when connected to a PC. Their terms & conds state they won`t pay for return postage, so even if I get a refund I`ll be out of pocket and have had a 2 month delay for my troubles.