Yes, my reading habbits were rather similar. I believe the first Amiga mag I read was AmigaPower after a family member brought one for me when I caught the flu.
From there, I progressed onto AmigaAction, although still enjoyed AmigaPower and occasionally AmigaFormat and TheOne. At this point, the contents of the front coverdisk (and whether it came with one or two disks...) largely dictated my magazine buying habbits.
However, this eventually changed as I gradually became more interested in utilities and public domain (oh man, public domain!); for this CU-Amiga, Amiga Computing and AUI provided my staple miggy diet.
Gosh, to think of the hours I would spent sitting on the toilet reading Amiga magazines from cover to cover - those were the days!
James