For a second I thought Red had come back...
Guess he's still mad at us.
This is a method I've used in the past with some success.
It's a bit extreme but will give you a 50/50 chance of finding the bad CIA first try.
Use that "hot finger" trick to get a good guess at which is the bad CIA.
Cut the pins away from your choosen CIA and remove it from the motherboard.
A sharp xacto blade makes a good tool.
Power up see if you get a screen. Yes? You found the bad CIA, yea!
No? Drat, it was the other one.
Of course a good amiga repair center is always the best ;-)
Plaz