Hi.
To answer a few of the questions...
I have a 1084s monitor & a Sony TV with video inputs, when I turn it on connected to the TV "NTSC" pops up onscreen so something is going on ( with the "good looking" board, I haven't tried the badly damaged one because it looks beyond repair)
I have removed all boards (Toaster, TBC's & Commodore 68030) and floppy cable
I had the +/-12 & +/-5 on the connector, but I noticed on the last pin (13 or 14) I had 2.5V, not sure if that is normal or not.
I had removed the 68000 to clean under it, used contact cleaner on the socket.
I will try swapping the CIA's & others, I don't have a chip puller for Agnus.
I still have one A2500 (with another toaster GVP 68030) that I have not taken apart yet, hopefully I can get at least one going!
Thanks for any hints, Len