I have all of my amigas without the rf shielding, and never had any problem with it. The a500 and a1200 ones that still are in his original cases, are without the shielding and work perfect. There is maybe another thing thats is producing that weird behaviour. Since you are using an a500, the problem maybe its on the a520 modulator. Does the shadow still applies when using the monochrome output of the 500?.