I agree that feedback is a joke for the very reasons stated above. I do not agree though that most transactions are neutral. If you buy something and pay immediatly, that is very positive. Not neutral in any way. If you wait 10 days to pay is that also the same neutral the immediate payer got? The same is true with the seller. If he ships right away and the item is as described or better that is very positive. If that is neutral what is it when the seller waits a week or 10 days to ship? It's not negitive because that still falls within accepted guidelines. But it certainly is true that you don't dare leave negative feedback or you will get it in return. But it also is true that some people wouldn't be happy if you hung them with a silk rope. You can't make them happy and that is what makes many sellers wait to leave feedback until they have it first. I do. I will say this for Boogiegail, he/she leaves immediate positive feedback and doesn't wait to get it first. That has to be taken into consideration as to why she gets as many negatives as she does. If she waited, others wouldn't be so quick to leave it (even if deserved) and her rating would be higher. And by the way, I still haven't received the $15 she owes me. Dan