A lot of people will get away with EDO with no trouble, and I'm sure I
irritate a lot by saying FPM is the best way to go.
However, I have come across 3x websites that say EDO is to be avoided
and did some research into EDO on other platforms.
Some Apple Macs have been fried by EDO (the really older Quadras I
think) and a lot don't work at all. Phase 5 say you can use EDO but
their manuals were written back in '94?. EDO had evolved
over the years after the Blizzards came out.
The PowerPC boards should be fine as they allow you to utilise an
`early ESC menu' on bootup to switch on/off the pre-charges. This
should alleviate problems with cheaper memory (which is invariably the
mass produced EDO).
Problems occur particularly when in use with the SCSI-IV kit, random
crashing, locking and phase changes. I used to get my machine locking
a lot with EDO and now it doesn't do it with FPM.
EDO may be totally compatible in most instances, but FPM will always
be totally accepted by all older 68k machines and so I'd take it as
the lowest common denominator. Amigas can't use the speed increase of
EDO anyway, your only advantage is that EDO is cheaper and more
plentiful. EDO is also usually thinner in size, but do you want to
sacrifice reliability (or at least the potential for unreliability) to
save a few bucks?
:-)