The Supra 2000 and A2058 are almost the same cards, so there should not be any difference.
But lets look at you RAM configuration:
1. A2091 with 2MB RAM, SCSI controller, you brobably need that RAM for SCSI
2. A2630 with 2MB RAM with 030 CPU, need that RAM also, w/o you probably loose some performance, and I'm not sure if you can disable it.
3. Supra 2000 with 6MB RAM, because you have 2MB + 2MB + 6MB, thats 10MB RAM, I'm pretty sure that 2MB is not allocated and it justs sits idle. You could just set the jumper to 4MB. BTW, I have exact RAM configuration as yours.
If you change the Supra for A2058 and remove the A2091, you will need to have 6MB on it, but the A2058 does not support 6MB configuration, so you are stuck.
The 9Mb is 1MB Chip RAM and 8MB Fast RAM. In OS 1.3 shows total RAM installed, in OS 2.X and 3.X the RAM is divided so you can see in workbench.