Many thanks for all the replies, I am genuinely shocked at the response!
I brought the CF drive as a 'A600 kit' so I don't think there is a special file system on it or it is a transfer rate issue. Having said that, I have nothing more than my sense of it feels like the issue is with the motherboard revision, as I am very green to the world of Amiga other than shoving disks in them!
It was sold as a kit by a reputable Amiga equipment supplier so I am sure there would be a disclaimer about an accelerator required if this was the case

Thank you everyone for your input
