Sounds like your power supply is weak or going bad if it's not strong enough to spin the HD, but the solid state stuff works. Try plugging the power supply of the GVP into it's own dedicated outlet, away from a surge protector that has a ton of other things plugged in... failing that, time to put a beefier supply on it (wattage beefier or replace with known good original).
Also, make sure the expansion port is clean...
Wait... is the HD8 the A2000 version? IF so, are you plugging power directly off the power supply into that card or relying on the expansion bus to power it? If so, that's prolly your problem...