I have an A2000 + video toaster + C=68030 accel, which originally had normal agnus. When I added a 1MB agnus from an A500, I had still 512k chip. I had to change a jumper and cut a solder bridge. Might check into how the accel is autoconfiguring the memory, check the amiga hardware database for jumper settings on your particular accel, or - yes - try another / reseat 1mb Agnus if you can.