I don't see intentional wrongdoing even in the latter case.
I don't either. I don't think, or at least I hope, no one is implying blatant piracy. It may very well be fine and dandy. OTOH if it turns out they were only licensed for the A1200 because of a special bundle deal AND the original author responds that he does not want it distributed any other way, then Eyetech would have to respond.