Well it's obvious that as a big brand consumer item the Amiga has been a long time dead.
At least we can all agree on that point.
On the subject of nostalgia, then why if it's just for the sake of nostalgia do some of the same people who voted no go on about looking forward to the continuing development of AROS, MorphOS and different processors to run as an Amiga, thats not nostalgia thats looking forward.
Never know what can spark something new and advanced Amiga-like OS. Find good hardware that an sell and it might bring enough interest back from Devs to work on something that is truly Next Generation.
I've been using classic Amiga's since the very start and still do to this very day, so as far as I'm concerned it's nothing to do with nostalgia as I always have and always will use my Amigas as my main computer system... 
Good for you. I as well as many others find it's not capable of doing modern day web browsing. Even the new OSs (MOS/OS4/AROS) lack hardware punch do to a lack of modern hardware or it's locked in step with 3.1 API that will not allow it to be fully use SMP hardware.
I see the poll result is a close race between Dead hardware and AROS on x86. Care to answer why that is Franko?