Hands up who thinks this is a really futile discussion!
:-)
IMO, Amiga is 99.9% about AmigaOS. Perhaps judging the AmigaOne/AmigaOS4 product once it has actually been released might make this a more worthwhile discussion.
People like what they like about the Amiga, and any related offspring, if it does what they want it to do, and nicely, what does it matter? If you choose to buy any computer, regardless of name, you should be judging it on what you believe are worthwhile merits, not someone else's opinion.