Besides the fact, that various niches within the greater amiga community have differing needs, making goals such as a pretty custom case or replacement motherboard, appeal to one group but not to another, nobody really believes Commodore USA is capable of producing the combination of hardware and software that can respect the Amiga past heritage and yet transcend it into something that would be considered desirable in today's more general consumer marketplace.
The fact they feel the need to ask publicly and take pre-orders, shows us they haven't done their home work and data mined past discussions as they should have...