Ratte, you are amazing! Can't wait to get home to test this tonight now.
EDIT:
I just switched over to this settings file for P96 and its very nice! Lots of screen modes in every resolution you would ever need. I'm still directly connected to the DVI on my Indivision AGA and the DVI on my Radeon PCI card, but will test it out using the VGA out directly on the radeon to make sure it stays full screen and centered out of the Radeon before making another attempt at the switch. Lets hope it works this time and displays properly! That switch is amazing.