I bought one of the 4000D faceplates, and it was in fact absolutely new--amazing, flawless condition. Only wish you could still get the case badges. ;-)
BTW, my first Amiga was purchased from SoftHut in the very early 90's, which I still have. (Yes, I was a bit late to the party.) I sold my comic collection to afford it... sometimes not sure if I'd rather still have the comics.
