Never another IBM drive for myself.
I've owned a few IBM "Deathstars" and they make that wonderfull click of death usually within 9 months.
And.. to add insult to injury, my GF's laptop has an IBM (Hitachi) Travelstar, which after 1 year light service now makes it's own unique click of death. All the SMART utilities i have say it's ok.. but that can't fool a wise one like me.. especially when I hear the Deathstar click and windows XP grinds to a screeching halt. Also, my IBM Travelstar off of e-bay failed in my Amiga 1200 after about 3 weeks of VERY light use..