Any AMOS-game. 'Nuff said.
Heyyyy... I thought Wheelchair Gladiators and Extreme Violence were awesome! That's about it, though.
Award for the most overrated game goes to Wrath of the Demon. I think that was the ultimate contrast between looks and playability.
Double Dragon 2 was pretty awful, too, but it was a hilarious kind of awful. :-D It's a shame I can't get my disk to boot, anymore.