Would anyone want to buy this, or is this probably counterfeit as well?
I would buy it, a NOS boxed CD32 in 2007 for £5 plus £25 P&P.
And the effort needed to counterfit a CD32 would be massive, re-make the PCB, chips, case etc. heck if it was a 2007 CD32 it would be worth a tonne.
As for the 5 negatives, well on a 99% feedback I would still take the risk... unless it was a DVD, then I wouldnt

----edit---
in typing my reply the price went from $9.99 to $62 O_O
still cheap IMHO