Yeah your crystal should be just fine, as should the 16Mhz one though (Although I guess you could get memory refresh problems)
Have you checked if all the jumpers are correct?
there is one for memory size, what OS your booting and some others.
Any missing chips or anything?
Have you tried removing the 68000 off your A2000 board? (Only needed in german A2000's but you can do it to any A2000)