Edit: Hmm, I'm blind, I admit it.
Personally, I think AmiDelf deserves some credit for doing this. I'm not a subscriber, but I believe he is doing this because he loves the Amiga as a computer (and not because he's worshipping any CEO).
And as for the competition:
Of course you've bloody got to be a member (subscriber) to enter the competition. It's the "you have to buy this product to enter the competition" that's illegal. I think in this case the wording is a bit wrong, because it's about membership in a club more than purchasing a product.
So cut the crap, cluebies.