I read the first "point" , fell about laughing, and read no further.
Since when is "why would anyone do that?" proof of innocence, or anything else?
Example:
We're currently - as a species - consuming the resources on this planet at such a speed that it would require 1.4 Earths to allow us to do this indefinitely. That's an average, of course: some people consume rather more (if you're reading this you're almost certainly amongst those who consume well over 2 Earths, probably 2.5 to 3 - I got down to 2.1 in the test by switching off as many electrical appliances as possible and going vegetarian. And I don't heat much in winter).
So we're burning up the resources on our planet faster than they can be renewed. That's stupid. Why would anyone want to do that?