It never said it was defective. This board ALWAYS showed up in the early config menu as working. However, I couldn't get it to work 1st due to incompatible driver disk I got off amiga hardware database (the download is for A2286 disk which has an incompatible janus.library), 2nd I insisted on using 4mb ZIP ram I was sure to be working, which turned out be defective (I verified this on my octagon board). Even with the faulty ram, it showed up as WORKING on the config menu. Though the janus.library didn't load properly, giving one long three short beeps. So I switched to 1mb ram, and everything was fine.
Now, I think you should learn some facts about the machine you're trying to use before you accuse people with ripping off ppl. Zorro2 bus has a limited memory space (8mb). All cards you install occupy a portion of this memory space, and anything over 8mb is unusable because of 68000 addressing limitations (Even if you have a 68020+ Zorro2 has this limitation). The faulty board notification in the early startup shows the bridgeboard is conflicting with some of your boards. Take your boards out and try again.