The funny digital connector is a DVI. ;-)
The monitor should be able to work with either connector, though you may need to set a switch or option on the monitor itself to tell it which input to use. Also, for the VGA-style connector, you'd need to make sure that you have a resolution/scan frequency within it's acceptable range.
Can you get an on-screen diagnostic menu from the monitor, itself? Or is the logic board in it fried, perhaps?