I may have a simplistic view, but I love the
Epyx 500XJ joystick.
Yep... Me too. I liked it better than the "gummy" Wico Ergo-Stick thing. Something about those durable click-switches, the short throws for movement in any direction, and the quick snap back of it. The beige/black Wico had problems with sticking in directions.
For conventional joysticks, I liked the big Wico arcade Red/Black sticks. Commanders, I think they were called?
The gravis analogs were awesome for all 3 games that supported analog... I also have an Epyx joystick that looks like a 500XJ that was cut up... It has two buttons, and an ANALOG stick. Strange thing, but works pretty well. Used to love it for FighterDuel. ;-)