Problems with HDF

[Lordberti]

Hello, what makes more sense — installing a system as a directory, or rather working with HDFs and e.g., PFS3? Which is the faster and more compatible option?
It would also be nice to be able to create an HDF, for example 4 GB for the Workbench and 64 GB for the Work partition. What’s the best way to do this?

The HDFs I previously used on the Raspberry Pi with DietPi and Amiberry are all not bootable on the A1200NG.

Maybe one of the testers with YouTube channels could pick this up sometime and make a well-explained, easy-to-follow video: creating an HDF, setting up PFS or SFS, and integrating it into the A1200NG.

[Lordberti]

Hi, there are a few things I really don’t get: Why don’t HDFs with RDB work? On other systems with PC/Mac Amiberry or WinUAE they do just fine. Also, why is there no option to create an HDF directly from the menu? That really needs to be added.
So far I haven’t been able to create a bootable HDF at all. Whenever I make an empty HDF in WinUAE — for example without an RDB — booting from the Installer 3.2 disk makes the mouse stop working. Overall, HDF handling just behaves really oddly.

[Lordberti]

I just tried it with an HDF without RDB – that works, the hard drive shows up and can be formatted. But what doesn’t work now, or at least I don’t know how it’s supposed to work without HDToolbox, is how to format it with PFS3. That only seems to work with RDB HDFs.
Right now the whole situation feels half-baked – proper RDB support like in WinUAE, Amiberry, or FS-UAE is really needed. Still, thanks a lot for taking the time to help me with my issue.

[Lordberti]

At the moment it apparently only works with CF cards, where there are no issues. With HDF files, however, the necessary support is missing – specifically the HDF handling with RDB support. There is no checkbox for that, and it would also be nice to have a direct option in the menu to create them, with or without RDB.