Well...
I do like the looks of the C64 casing clone, very nice, except it needs two C64 keys so I'd be able to do a soft reset in AROS, assuming it would run on the hardware if it comes out.
As for judgment. Well it has been a fun ongoing joke here in the community, so thus far we can all thank Barry for that! Now if he delivers a price effective product that will run AROS, I'll happily commend him. After all, this is a fun idea that I'm sure many of us have thought of our selves before C USA came around. So to Barry, I say GO FOR IT!
On the other hand, if they really are saying that Amiga has gone no where, and that they are the first to actually do something with the name...
...well they seriously need to kill that noise. It's LAME.
Lastly I must state that I'm VERY curious as to what Workbench 5 is! VERY!!! I'm not expecting much, but I'm damn curious! I'm willing to bet that it is some Linux concoction with an Amiga skin though. :/