The disqualifier was whether or not a device was reliant on mechanical devices to work; Computers were not- that is, the storing, the analyzing, and the calculating could all be done electronically. If it required mechanical parts to operate then, by definition, it was not a computer.
So, can you run your Vista box without a mechanical hard drive? My A1200 can. :-P
Who came up with that piece of crass stupidity?
Just how useful is you A1200 without hard drive or
floppy? How useful is a C64 without a disk drive or tape deck? Or indeed without a joystick as well?
To be honest, this is the real reason why the Amiga was never revived - incompetence and corruption notwithstanding. Too many amongst the Amiga die-hards are just not capable of thinking progressively and just live in some rose-tinted view of the past.
Personally, I think the Amigs should now be allowed to rest in honour. The name and brand have been dragged through the mud for long enough by people who claimed to have the community at heart but in fact just served their own inflated egos.