One thing I had considered though is this - when HDToolBox maps out a bad block or low level formats a hard disk, is this updated information stored somewhere on the platter or in the drive's logic?
If it's stored on the board then wouldn't replacing the platters be lethal?
Also, don't you really have to make sure you put the platters back in the right order? I imagine this would be for the very brave, no good leaving the room and coming back after forgetting what goes where!
It's reassuring what you say though, maybe we should all make a point of not only backing up our software - but backing up our hardware!
Race ya to eBay!