The Bug is not the most precise joystick I have (actually I seldom use it), but it quicker than yours. (the kids have my camera right now, so I can't even take a shot to show you) It does have a little play however - so maybe that's just something that happens with time & use?
I still prefer the old TAC 2 joysticks, or Mazemasters.
But, at best, joystick preferences is a very subjective topic.