It's not the companies that are doing the arguing, it's the people that have an opinion - nobodies actually said anything useful that explains the technical difficulties of porting it over (probably quite easy really) or what the differences in the hardware actually are.
I want a 'next generation' Amiga, the way Workbench works fits the way I think. I want good hardware, but I don't really care as long as I don't run out of {bleep}ing chip ram! I also don't mind paying for good hardware, in the time I've had one A3000 I've gone through 6 PCs and re-installed Windows many many times, and the A3000 is still quick to load and reliable - thats worth more than money as it's saving my time, the A3000 is soon to get it's first re-install in the last 5 years.
Now can anybody tell me facts or physical examples that are actually on topic? I would like to know, and not read more piles of steaming brown personal opinion.