Jesus, just because people used pirate copies of Carrier Command, it doesn't mean it's crap. Read the manual if you want to know what's going on. Carrier command has been a great game.
My list with the most crap Amiga Games:
-Metal Law (huge sprite with 2 frames for the movement)
-Rise of the robots
-Eat the Whistle (pile of ####e)
-Tube Warriors (AGA my ass)
-Championship Manager 2