@Holly
Get Halo 2. I just got it yesterday and it's great. I might have to sign up for Xbox Live now to try the multiplayer. (There are games on XBLink, etc. but I've heard the Live scene is better).
@All
I wasn't commenting on just Amiga piracy, but the piracy of arcade game roms, ie. MAME roms. There are few good games worth playing that aren't under copyright (ie. anything Capcom, Sega, Midway, Nintendo, etc.).
This isn't a question of morality, it's a question of legality. And, while I do agree that a moderator should not be busy "policing" this stuff. I feel they shouldn't openly support it.